People

Steve

What I wanted you to understand about finding my father, and eventually losing him again.

Steve,

Finding you was something I had wondered about for most of my life.

I grew up without knowing my biological father, and for a long time you existed more as an unanswered question than as an actual person. When the genealogist finally found you in 2020, I genuinely did not know what would come of it. I was curious, nervous, and probably more hopeful than I wanted to admit.

The timing was extraordinary. I first spoke to you on August 4, 2020, while Mom was already seriously ill with COVID. I met you in person for the first time on October 9. During that visit, I was also trying to communicate with Mom while she was gravely ill and largely unresponsive. I have always thought of that period as one parent fading into view while the other was fading out.

I am glad we met. I am glad I got to know where I came from, at least in part, and that there were moments between us that felt surprisingly normal considering how much time had passed.

But I also wish things had gone very differently.

What I wanted from you was never especially complicated. I wanted the opportunity to know my father as a person, slowly and honestly. I wanted some consistency. I wanted to be able to ask questions, spend time together, and see whether something resembling a relationship could develop after four decades apart.

Instead, over time, things became increasingly difficult. Reasonable requests became sources of anger. Conversations became hostile. And eventually, you began questioning the DNA evidence itself.

That remains one of the things I find hardest to understand or excuse.

You had already spoken to me as your son. You had met me in person. We had begun building some form of relationship on the basis of the genealogical work and DNA evidence that had brought us together. Then, after all of that, you started casting doubt on whether I was actually your son at all.

I want you to understand how extraordinary that felt from my side.

I had spent roughly forty years growing up without a father. I did not arrive in your life demanding money, status, or anything else from you. I wanted to know who my father was. After finally finding you, I allowed myself to believe that one enormous unanswered question in my life had finally been resolved.

For you to later question the DNA did not feel like skepticism about a laboratory result. It felt like you were reaching backward and attempting to erase the relationship itself.

If you genuinely believed the test was unreliable, you could have approached that concern carefully, asked for another test, or spoken to me like someone who understood the magnitude of what he was saying. Instead, the doubt emerged in the middle of an increasingly hostile relationship, which made it feel less like a good-faith scientific concern and more like rejection.

I think most people would understand why I found that appalling.

There are some things a parent can say in anger that cannot simply be pulled back later. Suggesting to a son who spent most of his life without you that perhaps you were never his father in the first place is one of them.

That hurt more than I think you ever understood.

There is a particular kind of pain in spending most of your life without a father, finally finding him, beginning to build some kind of relationship, and then having that same person reopen the most fundamental question of all: whether you belonged there in the first place.

Eventually I had to stop participating in the relationship.

I have wondered many times whether finding you was ultimately good for me. I still don’t have a clean answer. There were things I learned and moments I am glad I had, and I do not want to erase those. But there was also a great deal of disappointment attached to something I had already spent a lifetime learning not to expect.

I wish you had been able to meet me with more patience and curiosity. I wish disagreement had not so easily turned into anger. And I wish you had understood that questioning my paternity after we had already found one another was not some casual argument to throw into the pile. It struck directly at something that had shaped my entire life.

More than anything, I wish the fact that we had already lost forty years had made both of us more careful with whatever time remained.

I did want a relationship with you.

I just could not keep having one on terms that repeatedly left me hurt, angry, or wondering whether my own father was once again trying to make me disappear from his life.

Finding you answered one of the biggest questions of my life.

Questioning the DNA reopened it.

I only wish you had understood what that meant.