Jon
A long friendship, and the choices at the end that I cannot excuse.
Jon,
You were one of the closest things I ever had to a brother. I’ve known you since sophomore year of high school, stayed with you and your family at different points, and shared parts of my life with you that went far beyond an ordinary friendship. There is a lot of good history there, and I don’t want what happened at the end to erase it. You mattered enormously to me.
That is also why what you did hurt as much as it did. Somewhere along the way, you came to believe a version of me that I barely recognize. I don’t know how much of that came from Stephanie, how much you concluded yourself, or what conversations happened without me. What I do know is that someone who had known me for decades apparently reached very serious conclusions about me without giving me much opportunity to explain myself.
What happened with Rï is the part I have the hardest time getting past. I had arranged for her care because I wanted her protected if something happened to me, and you and Stephanie were the people I trusted enough to name. When circumstances changed and I told you I wanted my dog back, you had had her for only about five days. That same day, you tried to re-home her all the way to Sacramento. Until I asked for her back, there apparently had been no urgent need to do that. When you stopped responding, I came to your house because I could not get you to communicate with me about my own dog. You screamed at me, told me you wished I had died, and took a swing at me. I ended up having to call the police on someone I had once considered my brother.
There is something profoundly sad about that being one of the final chapters of a friendship that began when we were teenagers.
I can understand being angry with me. I can understand believing Stephanie, or deciding that you no longer wanted me in your life. What I cannot understand is choosing cruelty toward someone you had known for most of his life at one of the most vulnerable moments he had ever experienced. You could have spoken to me, told me what you believed, returned Rï, and then told me never to contact you again. Instead, you chose violence.
I wish things had ended differently between us. I will remember the teenager I met, the friend I grew up with, the person whose home was once also a place where I could stay, and all the years in which calling you my best friend made complete sense. But I will also remember what you did when I needed an old friend to show even basic humanity.
Both things are true. You were once family to me, and what you chose to become at the end permanently changed what that history means.
You said you wished I was dead: you got your wish.